MLB Free Agent Rankings 2025–26
Stars such as Alex Bregman, Pete Alonso, and Cody Bellinger join headliners Kyle Tucker, Dylan Cease, and Bo Bichette in a highly competitive 2025–26 MLB free agent class that features a strong mix of hitters and pitchers.
Kyle Tucker
Although injuries over the past two seasons affected Kyle Tucker’s value, he showcased some of the best offensive numbers of his career in 2024. Before a hand fracture in 2025, he had again started off impressively. The hand issue, along with a fractured shin the year before, appeared to be accidents rather than recurring problems.
Tucker has played 505 of 546 possible games in the prior four seasons, indicating a reliable track record. However, scouts have noted a decline in his speed and defensive range despite his solid base-running instincts.
Prediction: nine years, $360 million
Analysts suggest that Tucker might successfully transition to first base as his career progresses.
Dylan Cease
Dylan Cease’s earned run averages have varied, but his core pitching metrics have stayed consistent over the last five seasons. In his walk year with the Padres, he posted an 8–12 record with a 4.55 ERA, maintained a 30% strikeout rate, and posted a 3.46 expected ERA alongside a 3.58 SIERA. These figures reflect steady performance despite fluctuations in surface numbers.
Teams remain highly interested in Cease’s durability, as he has never missed a start since his debut in mid-2019, adding to his value as a reliable rotation arm. His potential for future Cy Young contention remains realistic given his consistency and stamina.
Key Strengths
- Consistent strikeout production and underlying stability
- Impressive record of durability and reliability
- Retains long-term potential for top-tier pitching awards
Author’s Summary
This MLB free agent class stands out for its depth, with stars like Tucker and Cease blending talent, resilience, and future promise in one of the most competitive markets in years.